Default Thumbnail

Groups dared to substantiate claims vs vaping bill with scientific evidence

December 6, 2021 People's Journal 312 views

CONSUMER advocates accused local anti-vaping groups funded by American charity Bloomberg Philanthropies of allegedly using tactics to sway lawmakers to reject Senate Bill 2239 which aims to regulate technology-aided alternatives to cigarettes.

In a joint statement, the National Consumers Union of the Philippines and Vaper AKO accused groups who were earlier identified in a congressional investigation as recipients of funds from charities of American billionaire Michael Bloomberg of employing tactics to discredit supporters of SB 2239.

“They are threatening to campaign against senators who are looking into a balanced, objective and evidenced-based regulation. This is not how we come up with laws that will benefit the public,” NCUP president Anton Israel said.

The NCUP and Vaper AKO also challenged anti-vaping organizations to substantiate their allegations against Senate Bill 2239 with scientific evidence, and not with pure insinuations. They issued the statement as the Senate continues to deliberate on SB 2239 which seeks to objectively regulate a much better option to cigarettes.

“Stop misinformation that causes unfounded fear that drives people away from abandoning smoking. If the vape bill is not passed into law, one million vapers will be driven back to smoking,” NCUP president Anton Israel said.

NCUP and Vaper Ako also questioned the agenda of the anti-vaping groups. “It’s ironic that these anti-vaping organizations, some led by doctors, are dismissing the voluminous scientific data supporting the merits of vaping and HTPs. Instead of objectively looking at the evidence, they use exaggerated tactics to keep adult smokers from having access to better alternatives,” Israel said.

Vaper AKO spokesman Joaqui Gallardo agreed, saying that the anti-vaping advocates are oversimplifying the smoking problem by stating that smokers can simply quit. “DOH data itself reflects only four percent of smokers are quitting despite existing approaches, while nations like UK, Japan and numerous European countries are seeing significant decline in smoking rates with the introduction of e-cigs and HTPs,” he said.

“So, what do these so-called health advocates want? They are pushing the 16 million Filipino smokers to their deaths by blocking their access to better alternatives,” Gallardo said.

Israel said a convenor of an anti-vaping group publicly contradicted herself by saying vaping causes cancer, while at the same time noting that it takes 20 years for cancer to develop.

“How can they make this hasty conclusion when clearly vaping has not been commercially available 20 years ago? She also said COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease) develops faster with vaping without citing scientific evidence. These reckless pronouncements will prevent smokers from moving away from the deadly cigarette instead of switching to a less harmful alternative that can potentially save lives.” he said.

Gallardo also expressed doubts on the credibility of the support the anti-vape group are getting.

“It’s impossible to believe that their baseless views, supposedly supported by different health associations, reflect the collective and honest stance of all the organizations’ members. It’s a fact that there are many local doctors who use and recognize that e-cigarettes are less harmful than smoking. And it’s lamentable that their voices are drowned out by these noisy minority who are peddling the narrative of their foreign funder,” Gallardo said.

The vape bill, according to Israel clearly states that minors are prohibited for accessing e-cigarettes and HTPs. He noted that a third of the version deliberated in the Senate is dedicated to protecting minors.

He also dismissed the claim that the Department of Trade and Industry has no capacity to regulate vapor products, while raising the objectivity issues of the Food and Drug Administration.