Default Thumbnail

Data on onion supply might be ‘fake’

February 9, 2023 Ryan Ponce Pacpaco 296 views

HIGH-ranking leaders of the House of Representatives were left with the impression that government data on the supply of onions, particularly those coming from the Department of Agriculture (DA), are being allegedly “invented” or “faked”.

This, as Majority Leader and Zambonga City 2nd District Representative Mannix Dalipe and Committee on Appropriations Senior Vice Chairperson and Marikina City 2nd District Rep. Stella Quimbo tried but failed to get satisfactory answers from the Bureau of Plant Industry (BPI) during Wednesday’s House inquiry on the alleged hoarding of onions and other agricultural products.

Earlier, Speaker Martin G. Romualdez warned unscrupulous businessmen suspected of hoarding onions and other agricultural products that their “days are numbered.”

The inquiry on the issue of hoarding–which is believed to be causing hefty price spikes on onions and other basic commodities–was carried out by the House Committee on Agriculture and Food.

The panel is chaired by Quezon 1st District Rep. Wilfrido Mark Enverga.

Among the initial “red flags” that Dalipe found during the hearing was the fact that Will Builders Inc. (WBI), one of the country’s largest cold storage firms, wasn’t listed in the BPI’s records. The BPI is an attached agency of the DA.

“Yung mga datos natin, artificial land ba yan? Pinepeke lang ba yan? ‘Di ba? May laman ba yung cold storage? Wala bang laman ‘yung cold storage? Kasi diyan mo malalaro ‘yung presyo,” Dalipe asked the BPI representative to the panel’s motu proprio hearing.

“What if the cold storage is empty, and your report says it’s full. What will happen to the market?… That will be taken advantage of by some people, na walang supply. Tataas ngayon ang presyo kasi mali ang datos niyo,” he said.

Dalipe said he believes that “price manipulation” is taking place in the local onion industry.

“There were reports that we had sufficient onion and garlic, and here come the months of October, November, December, na tumaas ‘yung presyo. If the reports were true [na sufficient], why would the price go up?” he noted.

“So anong ginagawa nung ahensyang nagmo-monitor? Totoo ba or peke ba ‘yung scenario ma may supply? Pineke ba ‘yung datos na may supply para sumipa ‘yung presyo, tumaas, para magkaroon ng opportunity ba ‘yung mga smuggler, ganun ba ‘yun? I’m getting suspicious already kasi parang may gumagawa ng scenario to create something, a scenario which makes it profitable,” the House Majority Leader further said.

Quimbo, an economist, grilled the BPI on the “doubtful” and unexplained figures it gave the Enverga panel.

As per the BPI, the annual increase in demand for onions from 2011 to 2021 was a steady 5%.

But from 2021 to 2022, there was a perplexing 39% increase in demand for onion.

“‘Yun ang para sa akin bagong misteryo. Paano nyo maipapaliwanag ‘yun. Taon-taon halos 5 percent lang ang pagtaas ng demand? Kasi taon-taon naman ang magdi-drive ng increase in demand for onion is population growth. Hindi naman nagbabago ang paggisa natin eh,” she said.

Turning to the resource persons from the DA, Quimbo asked: “May paliwanag ba kayo? Kasi kung wala kayong magandang paliwanag ng 39 percent increase in demand iniimbento ninyo ang datos na ‘to at dina-justify ninyo ang mataas na presyo ng sibuyas.”

Arnold Timoteo of the DA-High Value Crops Development Program replied that the demand was based on the per capita consumption provided by the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA).

He further said that they would revisit their data.

Quimbo requested that the panel invite the team from DA that furnished them with the data to the next scheduled hearing on February 14.

Enverga, for his part, admitted that he was “dismayed” with what he learned during the first day of the probe.

“Medyo disappointing dahil nga ‘yung data gaps between BPI, PSA. Medyo nalilito kami dito sa mga bagong rebelasyon namin dito. Even yung data nila particular dun sa mga cold storages,” he said.

“Again, nadismaya ako dun sa pagkakataon na madiskubre na ‘yung [onion] traders ay hindi alam ng BPI so malaking butas, ito particular for yung mga mapagsamantalang tao. Since hindi alam kung asan yung particular supply sa particular moment eh malaking problema natin dito,” he said.

“So medyo overwhelming na disappointing but we hope sa Tuesday (Feb. 14) ready naman yung mga agency na ni-require natin na pumunta dito,” Enverga added.

AUTHOR PROFILE